A series of spirocyclic compounds inspired by Eli Lilly's phase 1 antidiabetic FFA1 receptor agonist LY2881835 was designed to include polar aromatic periphery groups and explore a possibility of building additional contacts with the target near the agonist binding site. The frontrunner compound in the series (9i) was shown to be a potent (EC50 = 260 nM) FFA1 agonist with excellent aqueous (PBS) solubility and good Caco-2 permeability. The observed structure-activity relationships were rationalized by a docking study. The new series significantly expands the ligand landscape for the ongoing quest for new potent and more polar FFA1 agonists as fundamentally new class of therapeutic agents against type 2 diabetes mellitus.