Replicate 2-D gels were stained with four visible or fluorescent dyes using published procedures, and 48 co-detected spots were selected for contrasting values in abundance, M(r) and pI. Success rate of identification and sequence coverage were affected in a dye-dependent manner by the three parameters. Frequency of missed cleavages and recovery of sulfur-containing peptides also depended on the dye. Finally, the dataset was used to predict the number of proteins identifiable when integrating the differential contribution of each parameter. Sypro Ruby appeared to combine several favorable features: no dependence of the identification rate upon the physicochemical properties of proteins, no impact on frequency of missed cleavages, and a higher predicted identification rate.