Published in

Mineralogical Association of Canada, The Canadian Mineralogist, 1(49), p. 63-88

DOI: 10.3749/canmin.49.1.63

Links

Tools

Export citation

Search in Google Scholar

Oscillatory zoned liddicoatite from Anjanabonoina, central Madagascar. I. Crystal chemistry and structure by SREF and 11B and 27Al MAS NMR spectroscopy

This paper is available in a repository.
This paper is available in a repository.

Full text: Download

Red circle
Preprint: archiving forbidden
Red circle
Postprint: archiving forbidden
Red circle
Published version: archiving forbidden
Data provided by SHERPA/RoMEO

Abstract

The crystal structures of 23 samples extracted from a large slice oriented along (001) of a single crystal of liddicoatite from the Anjanabonoina granitic pegmatite in Madagascar (showing pronounced, visually discontinuous oscillatory zones and anomalous biaxiality) were refined to R1 indices of 1.5-2.9% (< R-1 > = 1.78%). Cell parameters are in the range a approximate to 15.82-15.87, c approximate to 7.10-7.12 angstrom. Spindle-stage measurement of 2V gave values of 0.0 degrees for a fragment from the (001) zone and 8(3) and 18.9(5) for fragments from the pyramidal zone of the crystal. However, single-crystal X-ray intensity data show no deviation from 3m Laue symmetry, indicating that there is no information in the diffraction data on any deviation from R3m symmetry. The < T-O > distances are in the range 1.616-1.619 angstrom, with a grand mean value of 1.6175(7) angstrom. The occupancy of the T site was expressed as xSi + (1-x) B, and x was treated as variable in the refinement procedure. The effect of using different scattering factors (i.e., ionized versus neutral) on the refined site-occupancies was investigated in detail. The grand mean refined [4] B content of the T site varies from -0.04 apfu for ionized scattering-curves for O and Si to 0.25 apfu for neutral scattering-curves for O and Si, illustrating the effect of the use of different scattering curves on refined [4] B site-populations. Examination of < T-O > distances as a function of aggregate cation radius for tourmalines containing ([4]) B and Al-[4] shows a large amount of scatter, emphasizing the need for more accurate data. The limits of detection for B-11 and Al-27 in tourmaline by Magic-Angle-Spinning Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (MAS NMR) spectroscopy were investigated by simulation. For minimum (< 0.04 apfu) and maximum (0.12 apfu) contents of (paramagnetic) transition metals, the limits of detection of B-[4] are similar to 0.02 and 0.08 apfu, and of ([4]) Al are similar to 0.01 and 0.01 apfu, respectively. B-11 and Al-27 MAS NMR spectroscopy gave no evidence of the presence of tetrahedrally coordinated B or Al at the T site above these detection limits in any sample. This result is in accord with our refinement results using an ionized scattering-curve for O and a neutral scattering-curve for Si, suggesting that use of these curves is giving more accurate results than refinement with neutral scattering factors. The < Z-O > distances are in the range 1.904-1.907 angstrom, with a grand mean value of 1.9047(8) angstrom, and structure refinement indicates site-scattering values in accord with complete occupancy of the Z site by Al. Hence throughout this complexly zoned crystal, Si = 6.00 apfu and Al-Z = 6.00 apfu.