Charge transport in a porphyrin with four identical pyridyl substituents, 5,10,15,20-tetra(4-pyridyl)-21H,23H-porphine (TPyP), was investigated using the scanning tunneling microscopy break junction method. To determine the dominant pathway, we studied two structurally similar porphyrins, o-DPyP and p-DPyP. Our experiments reveal that charge transport through TPyP in a break junction configuration does not follow the traditional assumption, i.e., the shortest path between the neighboring side groups. Instead, the charge transport pathway was dominated by the farthest anchoring groups. Furthermore, these single molecule experiments can distinguish between the two structural isomers, which is important in molecular discrimination, porphyrin chemistry, and molecular electronics.