Inconsistency and a lack of reproducibility are commonly associated with semi-automated segmentation methods. In this study, we developed an ensemble approach to improve reproducibility and applied it to glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) brain tumor segmentation on T1-weigted contrast enhanced MR volumes. The proposed approach combines samplingbased simulations and ensemble segmentation into a single framework; it generates a set of segmentations by perturbing user initialization and user-specified internal parameters, then fuses the set of segmentations into a single consensus result. Three combination algorithms were applied: majority voting, averaging and expectation-maximization (EM). The reproducibility of the proposed framework was evaluated by a controlled experiment on 16 tumor cases from a multicenter drug trial. The ensemble framework had significantly better reproducibility than the individual base Otsu thresholding method (p