CD8 T cells play a key role in defense against the intracellular parasite Toxoplasma but why certain CD8 responses are more potent than others is not well understood. Here, we describe a parasite antigen ROP5 that elicits a modest CD8 T cell response in genetically susceptible mice. ROP5 is secreted via parasite organelles termed rhoptries that are injected directly into host cells during invasion, whereas the protective, dense granule antigen, GRA6, is constitutively secreted into the parasitophorous vacuole. Transgenic parasites in which the ROP5 antigenic epitope was targeted for secretion through dense granules led to enhanced CD8 T cell responses, whereas targeting the GRA6 epitope to rhoptries led to reduced CD8 responses. CD8 T cell responses to the dense granule-targeted ROP5 epitope resulted in reduced parasite load in the brain. These data suggest that the mode of secretion impacts the efficacy of parasite-specific CD8 T cell responses.