Middle Triassic marine deposits of the Germanic Basin (Muschelkalk) record a significant proliferation of cementing bivalves from different families. Based on previously undescribed, excellently preserved material from the Willebadessen Member (late Anisian, Illyrian) of the Upper Muschelkalk Trochitenkalk Formation of Willebadessen (Germany), we propose the new genus Noetlingiconcha, type species N. speculostreum sp. nov., for strongly plicate prospondylids lacking auricles. The new genus differs from Terquemia and Enantiostreon in being plicate rather than costate, and from Newaagia in the absence of auricles. We demonstrate that N. speculostreum was invariably attached by its right valve, in contrast to an externally similar species from the Lower Muschelkalk Freudenstadt Formation (lower Anisian, Bithynian) that was exclusively cemented by its left valve and thus represents the geologically oldest known oyster species. Previous reports of amphi-pleurothetic cemented bivalve species from the Muschelkalk probably result from lumping together these two externally similar species. The constancy of sinistral attachment in the geologically oldest Ostreidae suggests that left-pleurothetic valve orientation was already established in the ancestry of this family. Palaeontological data are therefore in accordance with genetic and larval shell morphology analyses that identified Pterioidea as the sister taxon of Ostreoidea, because Pterioidea contains several Permian-Triassic genera with an anatomically lower left valve.