The induction of mineralization by microbes has been widely demonstrated but whether induced biomineralization leads to distinct morphologies indicative of microbial involvement remains an open question. For calcium carbonate, evidence suggests that microbial induction enhances sphere formation, but the mechanisms involved and the role of microbial surfaces are unknown. Here, we describe hydrozincite biominerals from Sardinia, Italy, which apparently start life as smooth globules on cyanobacterial filaments, and evolve to spheroidal aggregates consisting of nanoplates. Complementary laboratory experiments suggest that organic compounds are critical to produce this morphology, possibly by inducing aggregation of nanoscopic crystals or nucleation within organic globules produced by metabolizing cells. These observations suggest that production of extracellular polymeric substances by microbes may constitute an effective mechanism to enhance formation of porous spheroids that minimize cell entombment while also maintaining metabolite exchange. However, the high porosity arising from aggregation-based crystal growth probably facilitates rapid oxidation of entombed cells, reducing their potential to be fossilized.