Abstract Background Antimicrobial use in livestock is one of the factors contributing to selection and spread of resistant microorganisms in the environment. National veterinary antimicrobial consumption monitoring programs are therefore in place in a number of countries in the European Union. However, due to differences in methodology, results on veterinary antimicrobial consumption from these national monitoring programs cannot be compared internationally. International comparison is highly needed to establish regulations on veterinary antimicrobial use and reducing antimicrobial resistance. The aim of this study was to assess differences in the outcomes on veterinary antimicrobial consumption by applying three different sets of nationally established animal defined daily dosages to the same antimicrobial drug delivery dataset of Dutch pigs in 2012. Methods Delivery information for the complete Dutch pig sector for the year 2012 reported to the Netherlands Veterinary Medicines Authority (SDa) was analysed with three differently and nationally established animal defined daily dosages from the Netherlands and Denmark: the Defined Daily Dosage Animal NL (DDDA NL ), the Animal Daily Dosage DK (ADD DK ) and Defined Animal Daily Dosage DK (DADD DK ). For each applied Dutch product equivalent, Danish products were identified based on authorization for pigs, active substance (including form), administration route, concentration and dosage regimen. Results Consumption in number of ADD DK /Y was lower than in number of DDDA NL /Y for sows/piglets and finisher pigs, with proportions of 83.3 % and 98.3 %. Use in number of DADD DK /Y was even lower, 79.7 % for sows/piglets and 88.1 % for finisher pigs compared to number of DDDA NL /Y. At therapeutic group level proportions of number of DADD DK /Y to number of DDDA NL /Y were 63.6-150.4 % (sows/piglets) and 55.6-171.0 % (finisher pigs). Proportions were > 100 % for the polymyxines (sows/piglets 150.4 % and .