We used high-resolution phylogenetic methods in the context of mother-to-child transmission to obtain information on the timing of the infection and on the transmission network. A total of 33 pol sequences (from maternal peripheral blood, from breast milk, and from plasma of children) belonging to five cases of HIV infant transmission were studied. Using time-scaled phylogeny we were able to estimate that in two cases the transmission occurred after the recommended duration of breastfeeding, supporting a longer, not reported, duration of breastfeeding as a significant factor associated with HIV infant acquisition in this cohort. Among the postnatal infections we were also able to demonstrate that the cell-free virus in breast milk was the most likely population associated with the event of transmission. Our study showed that a coalescent-based model within a Bayesian statistical framework can provide important information that can contribute to optimizing preventive strategies.