We study the spatiotemporally chaotic dynamics of holes and defects in the 1D complex Ginzburg--Landau equation (CGLE). We focus particularly on the self--disordering dynamics of holes and on the variation in defect profiles. By enforcing identical defect profiles and/or smooth plane wave backgrounds, we are able to sensitively probe the causes of the spatiotemporal chaos. We show that the coupling of the holes to a self--disordered background is the dominant mechanism. We analyze a lattice model for the 1D CGLE, incorporating this self--disordering. Despite its simplicity, we show that the model retains the essential spatiotemporally chaotic behavior of the full CGLE. ; Comment: 8 pages, 10 figures; revised and shortened; extra discussion of self-disordering dynamics