Friction stir consolidation (FSC) is a promising manufacturing process for metal matrix hybrid composites (MMHC) with excellent mechanical properties. The originality of this study involves the exploration of the fabrication technique (FSC), the selection of materials and the optimization of wear behavior via a systematic investigation of the process parameters. The aim of this study was to optimize and investigate the wear behavior of MMHCs fabricated using FSC. The optimum sample was nominated for thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and wear morphology analysis using SEM imaging. Material compositions of 7.5%wt of SiC, 7.5%wt of ZrO2 and 85%wt of AZ61 were considered for the experimental investigation. The RSM Box–Behnken design followed by a genetic algorithm (GA) was implemented to optimize the process parameters of sliding distance, speed and load at 350 m, 500 m and 650 m; 220 rpm, 240 rpm and 260 rpm; and 20 N, 30 N and 40 N, respectively. The RSM Box–Behnken result showed that the minimum wear rate of 0.008 mg/m was obtained at 350 m, 20 N and 240 rpm, whereas GA predicted the optimum parametric setup at 350 m, 20 N and 220 rpm. Additionally, TGA showed the material’s thermal stability from 375 °C to 480 °C. Generally, MMHCs exhibited a promising wear performance, proving the effectiveness of the FSC.