Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is a pharmacogenetic condition of skeletal muscle that manifests in hypermetabolic responses upon exposure to volatile anaesthetics. This condition is caused primarily by pathogenic variants in the calcium-release channel RYR1, which disrupts calcium signalling in skeletal muscle. However, our understanding of MH genetics is incomplete, with no variant identified in a significant number of cases and considerable phenotype diversity. In this study, we applied a transcriptomic approach to investigate the genome-wide gene expression in MH-susceptible cases using muscle biopsies taken for diagnostic testing. Baseline comparisons between muscle from MH-susceptible individuals (MHS, n = 8) and non-susceptible controls (MHN, n = 4) identified 822 differentially expressed genes (203 upregulated and 619 downregulated) with significant enrichment in genes associated with oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) and fatty acid metabolism. Investigations of 10 OXPHOS target genes in a larger cohort (MHN: n = 36; MHS: n = 36) validated the reduced expression of ATP5MD and COQ6 in MHS samples, but the remaining 8 selected were not statistically significant. Further analysis also identified evidence of a sex-linked effect in SDHB and UQCC3 expression, and a difference in ATP5MD expression across individuals with MH sub-phenotypes (trigger from in vitro halothane exposure only, MHSh (n = 4); trigger to both in vitro halothane and caffeine exposure, MHShc (n = 4)). Our data support a link between MH-susceptibility and dysregulated gene expression associated with mitochondrial bioenergetics, which we speculate plays a role in the phenotypic variability observed within MH.