Abstract Transactive response DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) pathology is categorized as type A-E in frontotemporal lobar degeneration and as type α-β in Alzheimer disease (AD) based on inclusion type. We screened amygdala slides of 131 cases with varying ages at death, clinical/neuroimaging findings, and AD neuropathologic changes for TDP-43 pathology using anti-phospho-TDP-43 antibodies. Seven cases (5%) only showed atypical TDP-43 inclusions that could not be typed. Immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence assessed the atypical star-shaped TDP-43 pathology including its distribution, species, cellular localization, and colocalization with tau. All 7 had died at an extremely old age (median: 100 years [IQR: 94–101]) from nonneurological causes and none had dementia (4 cognitively unimpaired, 3 with amnestic mild cognitive impairment). Neuroimaging showed mild medial temporal involvement. Pathologically, the star-shaped TDP-43-positive inclusions were found in medial (subpial) amygdala and, occasionally, in basolateral regions. Hippocampus only showed TDP-43-positive neurites in the fimbria and subiculum while the frontal lobe was free of TDP-43 inclusions. The star-shaped inclusions were better detected with antibodies against N-terminal than C-terminal TDP-43. Double-labeling studies confirmed deposition of TDP-43 within astrocytes and colocalization with tau. We have identified a novel TDP-43 pathology with star-shaped morphology associated with superaging, with a homogeneous clinicopathologic picture, possibly representing a novel, true aging-related TDP-43 pathology.