Type 2 diabetes (T2D) has become a worldwide epidemic, primarily driven by obesity from overnutrition and sedentariness. Recent results reveal there is heterogeneity in both pathology and treatment responses in T2D patients. Therefore, a variety of T2D animal models are necessary to obtain a mechanistic understanding of distinct disease processes. T2D results from insufficient insulin, either due to beta cell loss or inborn deficiency. Although decreases in beta cell mass can occur through loss of identity or cell death, in this review, we will highlight the T2D animal models that display beta cell death, including the Zucker Diabetic Fatty Rat, sand rat, db/db mouse, and a novel diabetic zebrafish model, the Zebrafish Muscle Insulin-Resistant (zMIR) fish. Procuring a mechanistic understanding of different T2D progression trajectories under a variety of contexts is paramount for developing and testing more individualized treatments.