Currently, there is no robust evidence demonstrating a clear association between Lynch syndrome and non-malignant breast pathology such as adenomyoepithelioma. We report a case of benign breast adenomyoepithelioma, which after recurrence was associated with ductal carcinoma in-situ (DCIS) in a 41-year-old woman with Lynch syndrome, who lacked significant family history of breast or ovarian cancer. Both, the adenomyoepithelioma and DCIS were found to have nuclear loss of MSH2/MSH6 by immunohistochemistry, while germline testing confirmed MSH2 gene mutation. Concordant loss of MSH2 in both lesions in the context of a MSH2 pathogenic variant in this patient with Lynch syndrome illustrates that the benign adenomyoepithelioma behaved as a likely precursor of DCIS. Our report provides a novel perspective that in some patients with Lynch syndrome adenomyoepithelioma may represent a pre-malignant precursor lesion of DCIS.