Cells maintain a fine-tuned balance of deoxyribonucleoside 5′-triphosphates (dNTPs), a crucial factor in preserving genomic integrity. Any alterations in the nucleotide pool’s composition or chemical modifications to nucleotides before their incorporation into DNA can lead to increased mutation frequency and DNA damage. In addition to the chemical modification of canonical dNTPs, the cellular de novo dNTP metabolism pathways also produce noncanonical dNTPs. To keep their levels low and prevent them from incorporating into the DNA, these noncanonical dNTPs are removed from the dNTP pool by sanitizing enzymes. In this study, we introduce innovative protocols for the high-throughput fluorescence-based quantification of dUTP, 5-methyl-dCTP, and 5-hydroxymethyl-dCTP. To distinguish between noncanonical dNTPs and their canonical counterparts, specific enzymes capable of hydrolyzing either the canonical or noncanonical dNTP analogs are employed. This approach provides a more precise understanding of the composition and noncanonical constituents of dNTP pools, facilitating a deeper comprehension of DNA metabolism and repair. It is also crucial for accurately interpreting mutational patterns generated through the next-generation sequencing of biological samples.