Significance Defects in RNA quality control pathways manifest as disease because they function to selectively remove aberrant or defective species to ensure cellular homeostasis. The RNA exosome and TRAMP complexes encompass key components of the RNA surveillance machinery. Here we show that exoribonuclease activities of Rrp6-associated RNA exosomes protect stable RNA species from TRAMP-mediated polyadenylation and degradation, and that each catalytic activity of the RNA exosome-TRAMP complex contributes to substrate discrimination and degradation of less stable RNA species. Our results highlight a previously unappreciated role for Rrp6 in protecting stable RNA species from degradation and suggest additional mechanistic analogies between RNA and protein quality control pathways with respect to proofreading mechanisms that protect stable species while targeting unstable species for destruction.