T-cell products derived from third-party donors are clinically applied, but harbor the risk of off-target toxicity via induction of allo-HLA cross-reactivity directed against mismatched alleles. We used third-party donor-derived virus-specific T cells as model to investigate whether virus-specificity, HLA restriction and/or HLA background can predict the risk of allo-HLA cross-reactivity. Virus-specific CD8^pos T cells were isolated from HLA-A^*01:01/B^*08:01 or HLA-A^*02:01/B^*07:02 positive donors. Allo-HLA cross-reactivity was tested using an EBV-LCL panel covering 116 allogeneic HLA molecules and confirmed using K562 cells retrovirally transduced with single HLA-class-I alleles of interest. HLA-B^*08:01-restricted T cells showed the highest frequency and diversity of allo-HLA cross-reactivity, regardless of virus-specificity, which was skewed toward multiple recurrent allogeneic HLA-B molecules. Thymic selection for other HLA-B alleles significantly influenced the level of allo-HLA cross-reactivity mediated by HLA-B^*08:01-restricted T cells. These results suggest that the degree and specificity of allo-HLA cross-reactivity by T cells follow rules. The risk of off-target toxicity after infusion of incompletely matched third-party donor-derived virus-specific T cells may be reduced by selection of T cells with a specific HLA restriction and background.