There is now compelling evidence that the normal state of superconducting overdoped cuprates is a strange metal comprising two distinct charge sectors, one governed by coherent quasiparticle excitations, the other seemingly incoherent and characterized by non-quasiparticle (Planckian) dissipation. The zero-temperature superfluid density n_s(0)ns(0) of overdoped cuprates exhibits an anomalous depletion with increased hole doping pp, falling to zero at the edge of the superconducting dome. Over the same doping range, the effective zero-temperature Hall number n_{\rm H}(0) transitions from pp to 1 + pp. By taking into account the presence of these two charge sectors, we demonstrate that in the overdoped cuprates Tl_22Ba_22CuO_{6+δ}6+δ and La_{2-x}2−xSr_xxCuO_44, the growth in n_s(0)ns(0) as pp is decreased from the overdoped side may be compensated by the loss of carriers in the coherent sector. Such a correspondence is contrary to expectations from conventional BCS theory and implies that superconductivity in overdoped cuprates emerges uniquely from the sector that exhibits incoherent transport in the normal state.