The use of carbon nanomaterials (CNMs) in sensors and biosensor realization is one of the hottest topics today in analytical chemistry. In this work, a comparative in-depth study, exploiting different nanomaterial (MWNT-CO2H, -NH2, -OH and GNP) modified screen-printed electrodes (SPEs), is reported. In particular, the sensitivity, the heterogeneous electron transfer constant (k0), and the peak-to-peak separation (ΔE) have been calculated and analyzed. After which, an electrochemical amperometric sensor capable of determining uric acid (UA), based on the nano-modified platforms previously characterized, is presented. The disposable UA biosensor, fabricated modifying working electrode (WE) with Prussian Blue (PB), carbon nanotubes, and uricase enzyme, showed remarkable analytical performances toward UA with high sensitivity (CO2H 418 μA μM−1 cm−2 and bare SPE-based biosensor, 33 μA μM−1 cm−2), low detection limits (CO2H 0.5 nM and bare SPE-based biosensors, 280 nM), and good repeatability (CO2H and bare SPE-based biosensors, 5% and 10%, respectively). Moreover, the reproducibility (RSD%) of these platforms in tests conducted for UA determination in buffer and urine samples results are equal to 6% and 15%, respectively. These results demonstrate that the nanoengineered electrode exhibited good selectivity and sensitivity toward UA even in the presence of interfering species, thus paving the way for its application in other bio-fluids such as simple point-of-care (POC) devices.