Glioblastoma multiforme is one of the most malignant neoplasms among humans in their third and fourth decades of life, which is evidenced by short patient survival times and rapid tumor-cell proliferation after radiation and chemotherapy. At present, the diagnosis of gliomas and decisions related to therapeutic strategies are based on genetic testing and histological analysis of the tumor, with molecular biomarkers still being sought to complement the diagnostic panel. This work aims to enable the metabolomic characterization of cancer tissue and the discovery of potential biomarkers via high-resolution mass spectrometry coupled to liquid chromatography and a solvent-free sampling protocol that uses a microprobe to extract metabolites directly from intact tumors. The metabolomic analyses were performed independently from genetic and histological testing and at a later time. Despite the small cohort analyzed in this study, the results indicated that the proposed method is able to identify metabolites associated with different malignancy grades of glioma, as well as IDH and 1p19q codeletion mutations. A comparison of the constellation of identified metabolites and the results of standard tests indicated the validity of using the characterization of one comprehensive tumor phenotype as a reflection of all diagnostically meaningful information. Due to its simplicity, the proposed analytical approach was verified as being compatible with a surgical environment and applicable for large-scale studies.