Abstract Background Synthetic cannabinoid receptor agonists (SCRAs) are amongst the largest groups of new psychoactive substances (NPS). Their often high activity at the CB1 cannabinoid receptor frequently results in intoxication, imposing serious health risks. Hence, continuous monitoring of these compounds is important, but challenged by the rapid emergence of novel analogues that are missed by traditional targeted detection strategies. We addressed this need by performing an activity-based, universal screening on a large set (n = 968) of serum samples from patients presenting to the emergency department with acute recreational drug or NPS toxicity. Methods We assessed the performance of an activity-based method in detecting newly circulating SCRAs compared with liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry. Additionally, we developed and evaluated machine learning models to reduce the screening workload by automating interpretation of the activity-based screening output. Results Activity-based screening delivered outstanding performance, with a sensitivity of 94.6% and a specificity of 98.5%. Furthermore, the developed machine learning models allowed accurate distinction between positive and negative patient samples in an automatic manner, closely matching the manual scoring of samples. The performance of the model depended on the predefined threshold, e.g., at a threshold of 0.055, sensitivity and specificity were both 94.0%. Conclusion The activity-based bioassay is an ideal candidate for untargeted screening of novel SCRAs. The combination of this universal screening assay and a machine learning approach for automated sample scoring is a promising complement to conventional analytical methods in clinical practice.