Wildfires are a recurring hazard in forested catchments representing a major threat to water security worldwide. Wildfires impacts on water quality have been thoroughly addressed by the scientific community through field studies, laboratory experiments, and, to a lesser extent, the use of hydrological models. Nonetheless, models are important tools to assess on-site and off-site wildfires impacts and provide the basis for post-fire land management decisions. This study aims to describe the current state of the art of post-fire model adaptation, understanding how wildfires impacts are simulated and the options taken by the modelers in selecting parameters. For this purpose, 42 publications on modeling wildfire impacts on the hydrologic cycle and water quality were retrieved from the SCOPUS database. Most studies simulated post-fire hydrological and erosion response in the first year after the fire, while few assessed nutrients changes and long-term impacts. In addition, most simulations ended at the watershed outlet without considering the fate of pollutants in downstream waterbodies. Ash transport was identified as a major research gap, given the difficulties of its incorporation in the current models’ structure and the high complexity in predicting the heterogeneous ash layer. Including such layer would improve models’ ability to simulate water quality in post-fire conditions, being ash a source of nutrients and contaminants. Model complexity and data limitations influenced the spatial and temporal scale chosen for simulations. Post-fire model adaptations to simulate on-site soil erosion are well established, mainly using empirical equations extensively calibrated in the literature. At the watershed level, however, physical and process-based models are preferred for their ability to simulate more complex burned area characteristics. Future research should focus on the simulation of the ash transport and the development of integrated modelling frameworks, combining watershed and aquatic ecosystem models to link the on and off-site impacts of fires.