Objective The objective of this study was to identify essential aspects of exemplary post-discharge stroke rehabilitation as perceived by patients, care partners, rehabilitation providers, and administrators. Design We carried out an exploratory qualitative, multiple case study. Stroke network representatives from four regions of the province of Ontario, Canada each nominated one post-discharge rehabilitation program they felt was exemplary. Setting The programs included: a mixed home- and clinic-based service; a home-based service; a clinic-based service with a stroke community navigator and; an out-patient clinic-based service. Participants Participants included 32 patients, 16 of their care partners, 23 providers, and 5 administrators. Methods We carried out semi-structured qualitative interviews with patients and care partners, focus groups with providers, and semi-structured interviews with administrators. Health records of patient participants were reviewed. Using an interpretivist-informed inductive content analysis, we developed overarching categories and subcategories first for each program and then across programs. Results Across four regions with differing types of programs, exemplary care was characterized by three essential components: stroke and stroke rehabilitation knowledge, relationship built through personalized respectful care, and a commitment to high quality, person-centered care. Conclusion Exemplary post-discharge care included knowledge regarding identification and treatment of stroke-related impairment, that is, information found in best practice guidelines. However, expertise related to building relationship through providing personalized respectful care, within a mutually supportive, improvement-oriented team was also essential. Additionally, administrators played a crucial role in ensuring continued ability to deliver exemplary care.