Preservation of facial nerve function (FNF) during neurosurgery for cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumors is paramount in elderly patients. Corticobulbar facial motor evoked potentials (FMEPs) allow assessment intraoperatively of the functional integrity of facial motor pathways, thus improving safety. We aimed to evaluate the significance of intraoperative FMEPs in patients 65 years and older. A retrospective cohort of 35 patients undergoing CPA tumors resection was reported; outcomes of patients aged 65–69 years vs. ≥70 years were compared. FMEPs were registered both from upper and lower face muscles, and amplitude ratios (minimum-to-baseline, MBR; final-to-baseline, FBR; and recovery value, FBR minus MBR) were calculated. Overall, 78.8% of patients had a good late (at 1 year) FNF, with no differences between age groups. In patients aged ≥70 years, MBR significantly correlated with late FNF. At receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis, in patients aged 65–69 years, FBR (with 50% cut-off value) could reliably predict late FNF. By contrast, in patients aged ≥70 years, the most accurate predictor of late FNF was MBR, with 12.5% cut-off. Thus, FMEPs are a valuable tool for improving safety in CPA surgery in elderly patients as well. Considering literature data, we noticed higher cut-off values for FBR and a role for MBR, which suggests an increased vulnerability of facial nerves in elderly patients compared to younger ones.