OBJECTIVE Vertebral artery injury (VAI), a complication of blunt trauma, may cause posterior circulation stroke. An association of disease severity, classified in Denver grades, with stroke risk has not been shown. Using a literature-based analysis, the authors estimated the incidence of VAI following blunt trauma with the aim to investigate the impact of Denver grade and bilateral VAI on stroke occurrence. METHODS A systematic review of the literature on VAI following blunt trauma was conducted, and data on its incidence, the severity per Denver grade, and stroke occurrence were collected. The incidence of VAI and stroke occurrence were analyzed cumulatively and between Denver grades. A meta-analysis with random-effects models was performed. RESULTS Fifty-six studies including 2563 patients were identified. The overall incidence of VAI was 0.49% among blunt trauma cases and 14.5% among patients screened via any type of angiography. The incidence rates of bilateral VAI and concurrent carotid injury among all VAIs were 12.3% and 19.2%, respectively. VAI severity by Denver grade was as follows: grade I, 23.4%; grade II, 28.2%; grade III, 5.8%; grade IV, 42.1%; and grade V, 0.5%. The overall stroke risk was 5.32%, differing significantly among lesions of different Denver grades (p = 0.02). Grade III and IV lesions had the highest stroke prevalence (9.8% and 10.9% respectively), while strokes occurred significantly less frequently in patients with grade I and II lesions (1.9% and 3.0%, respectively). Denver grade V cases were too rare for meaningful analysis. Bilateral VAI was associated with a 33.2% stroke prevalence. The association between Denver grade and stroke occurrence persisted in a sensitivity subanalysis including only unilateral cases (p = 0.03). CONCLUSIONS VAI complicates a small yet nontrivial fraction of blunt trauma cases, with Denver grade IV lesions being the most common. This is the first study to document a significantly higher stroke prevalence among grade III and IV VAIs compared with grade I and II VAIs independently from bilaterality. Bilateral VAIs carry a significantly higher stroke rate.