Abstract The syntheses of FeS₂ and Fe₃S₄ nanomaterials were optimized using a novel facile, surfactant-free, and microwave-assisted, one-pot synthesis method, run under ambient and reasonably mild reaction conditions. Synthetic parameters, such as metal precursor salt identity, reaction time, reaction temperature, metal:sulfur molar ratios, and solvent combinations, were all systematically investigated and optimized. A series of FeS₂ (pyrite) samples was initially fabricated using thioacetamide (TAA) as the sulfur precursor to generate a distinctive, uniform octahedra-based morphology. Switching the sulfur precursor from TAA to L-cysteine resulted in a corresponding transformation in not only chemical composition from FeS₂ to an iron thiospinel structure, Fe₃S₄ (otherwise known as greigite), but also an associated morphological evolution from octahedra to nanosheet aggregates. The study of these materials has enabled crucial insights into the formation mechanisms of these materials under a relatively non-conventional microwave-assisted setting. Furthermore, in separate experiments, multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWNTs) and graphene were added in with underlying metal sulfide species to create conductive Fe–S/MWNT composites and Fe–S/graphene composites, respectively. The method of addition of either MWNTs or graphene was also explored, wherein an ‘ex-situ’ synthetic procedure was found to be the least disruptive means of attachment and immobilization onto iron sulfide co-reagents as a means of preserving the latter’s inherent composition and morphology. The redox acidity for the parent material and associated composites demonstrates the utility of our as-developed synthetic methods for creating motifs relevant for electrochemical applications, such as energy storage.