(1) Background: As elements of the standard admission blood panel, lactate and glucose represent potential biomarkers for outcome prediction. In patients with intracranial hemorrhage (ICH), data on the predictive value of these blood values is exceedingly sparse. (2) Methods: Between 2014 and August 2020, all patients with deep-seated ICH referred to the neurovascular center at the authors’ institution were included in the subsequent study. Serum levels of lactate and glucose at the time of admission were compared with mortality at 90 days. In addition, a multivariate analysis was performed in order to identify independent admission predictors for 90-day mortality. (3) Results: Among the 102 patients with deep-seated ICH, elevated lactate and glucose levels on admission were significantly associated with increased mortality at 90 days. Multivariate logistic regression analysis identified “ICH score ≥ 3” (p = 0.004) along with “admission hyperlactatemia” (p = 0.025) and “admission hyperglycemia” (p = 0.029) as independent and significant predictors of 90-day mortality in patients with deep-seated ICH. (4) Conclusions: Initially elevated lactate and glucose levels after spontaneous intracerebral hemorrhage are associated with poor outcome, suggesting a potential application for future prognostic models when considered in conjunction with other parameters.