Significance Silicate Earth is widely considered identical to chondrites in its refractory lithophile element ratios. However, its subchondritic Nb/Ta signature deviates from the chondritic paradigm. To resolve this Nb deficit, its sequestration in Earth’s core under very reducing core-forming conditions has been proposed based on low-pressure data. Here, we show that under conditions relevant to core formation Nb is siderophile at high pressures under all redox conditions, corroborating Nb inventory in Earth’s core. Further core formation modeling shows that Earth’s core could have formed under moderately reducing or oxidizing conditions, whereas highly reducing conditions mismatch the geochemical observables; although Earth may have sampled a variety of reservoirs, it is problematic to accrete primarily from materials as reduced as enstatite chondrites.