Staphylococcus aureus is a leading agent of antibiotic-resistant bacterial infections in the world. S. aureus tightly controls metal homeostasis during infection, and disruption of metal uptake systems impairs staphylococcal virulence. We identified small molecules that interfere with metal handling in S. aureus to develop chemical probes to investigate metallobiology in this organism. Compound VU0026921 was identified as a small molecule that kills S. aureus both aerobically and anaerobically. The activity of VU0026921 is modulated by metal supplementation, is enhanced by genetic inactivation of Mn homeostasis genes, and correlates with increased cellular reactive oxygen species. Treatment with VU0026921 causes accumulation of multiple metals within S. aureus cells and concomitant upregulation of genes involved in metal detoxification. This work defines a small-molecule probe for further defining the role of metal toxicity in S. aureus and validates future antibiotic development targeting metal toxicity pathways.