Mitochondrial TCA cycle dehydrogenase enzymes have been shown to be stimulated by Ca2+ under various substrate and ADP incubation conditions in an attempt to determine and understand the role of Ca2+ in maintaining energy homeostasis in working hearts. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that, at physiological temperature and 1 mm extramitochondrial free magnesium, Ca2+ can stimulate the overall mitochondrial NAD(P)H generation flux in rat heart mitochondria utilizing pyruvate and malate as substrates at both subsaturating and saturating concentrations. In both cases, we found that, in the physiological regime of mitochondrial oxygen consumption observed in the intact animal and in the physiological range of cytosolic Ca2+ concentration averaged per beat, Ca2+ had no observable stimulatory effect. A modest apparent stimulatory effect (22–27%) was observable at supraphysiological maximal ADP-stimulated respiration at 2.5 mm initial phosphate. The stimulatory effects observed over the physiological Ca2+ range are not sufficient to make a significant contribution to the control of oxidative phosphorylation in the heart in vivo.