Significance Engineered cardiac muscle can be used to promote the structural and functional maturation of human pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (hPSC-CMs). However, previous studies have not yet produced cardiac tissues with metabolic and proliferative maturation. Here, we develop a 96-well screening platform and screen for cardiac maturation conditions in engineered cardiac muscle. We found that simulating the postnatal switch in metabolic substrates from carbohydrates to fatty acids promoted a switch in metabolism, DNA damage response, and cell cycle arrest in hPSC-CM. Our study shows that this mechanism can be harnessed to enhance the maturation of human hPSC-CM and cardiac tissues, which has major implications for stem cell sciences, drug discovery, and regenerative medicine.