AbstractLeaf respiration in the dark and its C isotopic composition (δ¹³C_R) contain information about internal metabolic processes and respiratory substrates. δ¹³C_R is known to be less negative compared to potential respiratory substrates, in particular shortly after darkening during light enhanced dark respiration (LEDR). This phenomenon might be driven by respiration of accumulated ¹³C‐enriched organic acids, however, studies simultaneously measuring δ¹³C_R during LEDR and potential respiratory substrates are rare. We determined δ¹³C_R and respiration rates (R) during LEDR, as well as δ¹³C and concentrations of potential respiratory substrates using compound‐specific isotope analyses. The measurements were conducted throughout the diel cycle in several plant species under different environmental conditions. δ¹³C_R and R patterns during LEDR were strongly species‐specific and showed an initial peak, which was followed by a progressive decrease in both values. The species‐specific differences in δ¹³C_R and R during LEDR may be partially explained by the isotopic composition of organic acids (e.g., oxalate, isocitrate, quinate, shikimate, malate), which were ¹³C‐enriched compared to other respiratory substrates (e.g., sugars and amino acids). However, the diel variations in both δ¹³C and concentrations of the organic acids were generally low. Thus, additional factors such as the heterogeneous isotope distribution in organic acids and the relative contribution of the organic acids to respiration are required to explain the strong ¹³C enrichment in leaf dark‐respired CO₂.