A dense late Neogene history of pocket gophers from the Meade Basin of south-western Kansas and north-western Oklahoma preserves a detailed record of size change, as indicated by mean length of the lower fourth premolar. A ‘time for space substitution’ interpretation results in the tentative recognition of a pattern analogous to character displacement, in which the small to medium-sized Pliogeomys buisi, P. louderbachi, Geomys minor and G. floralindae are considered ecological analogues and treated as a single ecological entity, Avatar A. The larger G. jacobi and G. quinni are combined as Avatar B. Statistical analyses confirm that populations of Avatar A are of equal size when allochronic from Avatar B, and significantly smaller when synchronic (and sympatric) with Avatar B. However, this pattern is complicated by the observation that Avatar A began dwarfing before the appearance of Avatar B. This historical perspective suggests that static size patterns among modern taxa may have a complex history. Occasional diminutive geomyid transients (G. adamsi, Thomomys cf talpoides) are always paired with significantly larger, medium-sized Geomys. Although a random walk explanation for the pattern of size changes is unlikely, we are currently unable to distinguish between environmental change and competition as the likely forcing mechanisms.